General
- Prenatal surgery before 26/40 vs standard postnatal repair
Outcomes
- 12 months:
- composite of foetal or neonatal death or the need for shunt
- 30 months:
- composite of mental development and motor function
Results
- Stopped after the recruitment of 183/200 patients
- 158 patients whose children were evaluated at 12 months
- Prenatal surgery resulted in improvement in the composite score for mental development and motor function at 30 months (P=0.007) and in improvement in several secondary outcomes, including hindbrain herniation by 12 months and ambulation by 30 months
- Prenatal surgery increased risk of preterm delivery and uterine dehiscence at delivery
ㅤ | Pre-natal Surgery | Post-natal Repair | ㅤ |
Primary Outcome | 68% | 98% | p<0.001 |
Shunt Placement | 40% | 82% | p<0.001 |
Conclusion
- Prenatal surgery for myelomeningocele reduced the need for shunting and improved motor outcomes at 30 months but was associated with maternal and fetal risks
Houtrow et al 2021
- Further analysis of the MOMS trial
- functional mobility and motor levels are improved for children who underwent prenatal myelomeningocele repair vs standard postnatal repair.
Complications
- Babies do better (at least in the short term) with open fetal surgery BUT
- The mother carries an increased risk of:
- Ruptured uterus in the current and future pregnancies
- Uterine dehiscence
- 35% of women who underwent prenatal surgery had an area of dehiscence or a very thin pre-natal uterine scar at the time of delivery
- 10% of women who have a hysterotomy will rupture their uterus in their next pregnancy
- Possibly fetoscopic repair MMC to reduce risk
- Verbeek 2011
- Fetoscopic group versus postnatal repair group:
- Born earlier (32 wks [25–34] vs 39 wks [34–41])
- More obstetric complications (chorio, PPROM, oligo)
- More NICU ventilation and RDS
- BUT:
- Better neurological function preservation (mean of 2 segments better)
- Better knee jerk and anal sphincter reflexes
- Obligatory preterm cesarean section (usually 34–35 weeks)
- Repeat CS for all future pregnancies
- Increased risk of placenta percreta and death in future pregnancies
- Maternal outcome:
- Chorioamniotic membrane separation — 20 (26%)
- Pulmonary edema — 5 (6%)
- Modified biophysical profile <8 — 13 (17%)
- Oligohydramnios — 16 (21%)
- Placental abruption — 5 (6%)
- Gestational diabetes — 4 (5%)
- Chorioamnionitis — 2 (3%)
- Preeclampsia or gestational hypertension — 3 (4%)
- Spontaneous membrane rupture — 36 (46%)
- Spontaneous labor — 30 (38%)
- Blood transfusion at delivery — 7 (9%)
- Status of hysterotomy site at delivery:
- Intact, well-healed — 49/76 (64%)
- Very thin — 19/76 (25%)
- Area of dehiscence — 7/76 (9%)
- Complete dehiscence — 1/76 (1%)
- Fetal or neonatal outcome:
- Bradycardia during fetal or neonatal repair — 8 (10%)
- Perinatal death — 2 (3%)
- Gestational age at birth — 34.1±3.1 weeks
- Gestational age at birth (number [%]):
- <30 wk — 10 (13%)
- 30–34 wk — 26 (33%)
- 35–36 wk — 26 (33%)
- ≥37 wk — 16 (21%)